Ice Cream Shops to Try Out in Tallahassee

By Amy Marcos | Photo: David Calavera

With the fluctuating Tallahassee weather bringing 80 degree weather overnight seemingly every other day, only one food can quench the heat: ice cream. Fortunately for Tallahassee residents, the city has numerous locally-owned, delicious ice cream shops all over town. Check out this list of ice cream shops to try out.

Lofty Pursuits — A Tallahassee foodie staple, Lofty Pursuits, affectionately called “Lofty,” is an old-fashioned soda and ice cream shop located in Market Square. First opened in 1993 as a small skill toy shop, over the years, Lofty has become a classic Tallahassee ice cream stop. In addition to ice cream, they make and serve candy and brunch items. 

(Photo: Lofty Pursuits)

Barb’s Southern Style Gourmet — This gourmet ice cream and brittle shop, located at The Cottages at Lake Ella, sells yummy, homemade, popular “brittle ice creams.” Most known for their special brittles, Barb’s Southern Style Gourmet also sells cookies and gift baskets. 

(Photo: Barb’s Southern Style Gourmet)

Sugar Rush Bar — Sugar Rush Bar, located in the All Saints district and in Bannerman Crossings, is Tallahassee’s first milkshake bar. Serving ice cream, milkshakes, candy, and other tasty desserts, Sugar Rush Bar is known for its whimsy, over-the-top, handcrafted milkshakes. 

Magda’s — This ice cream shop, located in the heart of Collegetown, sells yummy ice cream, sweets, and coffee and is the perfect place to stop in for a quick sweet treat. With handmade waffle cones, unique toppings like cold brew brownie bites and fruity pebbles, and breakfast items available, all ice cream lovers should check out this shop.

(Photo: Magda’s)

2 thoughts on “Ice Cream Shops to Try Out in Tallahassee

  1. I would steer clear of sugar rush unless you have a LOT of time to kill and money to spend. Talking 3 hours for a cone! Tried it again recently and nothing has changed! Over an hour wait and wayyy overpriced. Unprofessional staff too.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s